There are very few large hotel properties in the Hamilton area. Colgate Inn and Wendt Inn are the largest. But being bed & breakfast people we have to recommend some of the great small properties. All varying in design and quality.
Patricia's B&B
http://www.patriciasguesthouse.com/
315-824-3162
Colgate Inn
http://www.colgateinn.com/
315-824-2300
Block of rooms under Hayes-Carlson
Manor on the Green - a village guesthouse:
http://bettywebb1947.wixsite.com/manor-on-the-green
607-316-0464
Holcomb's B&B
http://holcombsbandb.com
315-228-2120 / 315-824-3901
Peaceful Pines
http://www.peacefulpinesbandb.com/
315-824-2469
Wendt University Inn
http://www.wendtinn.com/index.html
315-824-4400 / 800-218-5449
More Lodging options at other small bed & breakfasts & cottage rentals:
Colgate University Lodging List